Casey & Tim — “Leather and Lace”

After Tyler’s shocking elimination, we wondered what other surprises were in store for us.

It was time for Team Adam to take the stage and the dueling contestants couldn’t be more opposite:

On the one side, we have Casey Weston, an adorable 17-year-old with sweet, but strong vocals.

She grew up playing sports and only found out a few years ago that she had a knack for singing.

Then we have Tim Mahoney, the king of almost. He’s a veteran of the music business, but he just hasn’t found his big break yet.

WINNER: Casey